What Happens If You Eat Expired Miracle Whip Cream?

If you are a Kraft Miracle Whip Cream fan, you may be wondering how long it will last and if it can go bad.

Miracle Whip is often used as a substitute for mayonnaise due to its lower cost and calorie content. 

What happens if you eat expired miracle whip?

Miracle Whip Cream is a popular condiment often used as a substitute for mayonnaise due to its lower cost and calorie content.

An unopened jar of Miracle Whip typically has a shelf life of six months from the manufacturing date when stored in the refrigerator.

If stored in the freezer, an unopened jar of Miracle Whip may be able to last up to a year, but it is important to take precautions to avoid contamination when using the contents.

If the Miracle Whip is chilled and not used frequently, it may last up to six months.

However, it is worth noting that Miracle Whip has higher water content and is lower in calories than mayonnaise.

Still, it also contains high fructose corn syrup, which may make it a less health-conscious choice as an egg substitute.

It is always best to consider food products’ ingredients and nutritional value when making dietary choices.

Miracle Whip Shelf Life



Unopened bottles of non-refrigerated Miracle Whip should be consumed within a week past the best-by date to ensure the best quality and safety.

Suppose the Miracle Whip has not been refrigerated and is more than a month past its expiration date. In that case, it is not advisable to consume it as it may contain the potentially harmful botulinum toxin.


Unopened Miracle Whip jars stored in the refrigerator can last up to two months past their best-by date.



An opened jar of non-refrigerated Miracle Whip Cream should be used within one week if not stored properly at room temperature.

Dishes prepared with mayonnaise, such as tuna salad, should be stored in the refrigerator to prevent spoilage and used within twenty-four hours if not stored properly.

If you do not have access to a refrigerator and need to purchase mayonnaise for salad dressing, it is best to store it in a dark, cool place away from direct sunlight.

Most mayonnaise can last up to one week in an open jar if stored in a shelf-stable state.


If stored in the refrigerator, an opened jar of Miracle Whip can last for several months.

However, it is important to be mindful of contamination when using the contents repeatedly.

To prevent contamination, it is best to divide the contents into smaller portions using plastic wrap based on the amount you need.

This will help to keep the remaining Miracle Whip fresh and prevent the risk of food poisoning.


If stored in the freezer, an opened jar of Miracle Whip Cream can last up to a year.

While the flavor and consistency may be different from when fresh, it is still safe to eat.

If you have an excess jar of mayonnaise that you do not plan to use soon, you can freeze it to prevent contamination.

Just be aware that the texture and flavor may change after freezing and defrosting.

How to Know if Miracle Whip Has Gone Bad


A strong, pungent smell is one of the signs that your Miracle Whip Cream has gone bad. If the product has an unpleasant, sharp smell, it is likely unsafe to eat. 


An expired Miracle Whip Cream may have a different color than when it was first opened.

The color may appear brownish or darker, similar to peanut butter, depending on how long it has expired and the temperature and bacterial contamination it has experienced. 


When mayonnaise or Miracle Whip Cream expires, it may change in texture, becoming thicker and potentially lumpy.

If left exposed to humid air, the texture may solidify over time. Bacteria may also grow and produce a toxin called botulinum, which can be harmful if ingested. 

Loss of Flavor

If Miracle Whip Cream has gone bad, its flavor will change and become unpleasant.

The original flavors of garlic, herbs, and paprika may be lost and replaced with a spoiled taste.

Can you eat Miracle Whip past the expiration date?

It is possible to eat Miracle Whip Cream a week past its expiration date if stored in a non-refrigerated environment.

However, the safety of consuming expired Miracle Whip depends on its storage conditions. It may be safe to consume up to a month past its expiration date if refrigerated.

However, it is important to note that expired Miracle Whip may have changed in texture, flavor, and smell, which can potentially lead to food poisoning. 

Is Miracle Whip mayonnaise?

Miracle Whip Cream is not the same as mayonnaise. While it contains similar ingredients, such as soybean oil and eggs, and has a similar sour flavor, it differs in its nutritional content.

Specifically, Miracle Whip has more sugar than mayonnaise. It is important to be aware of the differences between these products and to choose the one that meets your specific dietary needs and preferences.

Miracle Whip Cream has a shelf life of six months, depending on how it is stored.

If your Miracle Whip has expired and is no longer safe, consider making homemade mayonnaise using eggs and other condiments.

It is important to pay attention to the signs of spoilage in Miracle Whip, such as changes in texture, flavor, and smell, to prevent the risk of food poisoning.